Are Longfin Smelt Going Extinct?

long fin smelt

Longfin Smelt are a native Bay-Delta fish and are listed under the California Endangered Species Act as “threatened”. Like the Delta Smelt, Longfin have undergone dramatic declines over the past several decades starting with the 1987-92 drought, then the 2001-2005 dry period, the 2007-09 drought, and the most recent 2012-15 drought (Figure 1). A strong recovery occurred in the wet years of 1995-2000. Modest recoveries occurred in 2006 and 2011 (wet years).

The Winter Kodiak Trawl Survey of adult Longfin Smelt provides the first clue as to how the population is faring in the 2015 drought after the second lowest fall index on record. The number of adult Longfin captured in the three winter surveys (Jan-Mar) are low but not unlike other low abundance years in the past decade (Figure 2).

Another indicator is results of the Smelt Larval Survey. The abundance and distribution of larvae in the Bay-Delta is representative of spawning success and potential of this year’s production to contribute to the population. So far in March 2015, survey capture densities have been generally below 100 per 1000 cubic meter sampled (Figures 3 and 4). These densities were slightly lower than for the same surveys in 2014 (Figures 5 and 6). Much higher densities occurred in years 2009-2013 (not shown).

The Juvenile or 20-MM Smelt Survey is another indicator of how Longfin Smelt are faring. Its first survey was recently completed (Figure 7), and the densities are again down from 2014 (Figure 8). Densities in 2014 and 2015 are again significantly lower than in surveys over the previous decade (not shown).

Based on these trends, we can expect another poor recruitment year, perhaps even a record low Fall Index. The population was able to rebound after low Fall indices in 1992 and 2007. It remains to be seen whether the population can rebound after declining since 2006 and after record low numbers of larvae and juveniles in 2014 and 2015. As in 2014, water quality standards for Delta outflow and exports, as well as salinity, have been relaxed, which will further stress the population toward possible extinction. This “canary in the coal mine” for the San Francisco Bay-Delta Estuary, like the Delta Smelt, remains on “life support”.

We will keep you posted as to how the year progresses for Longfin Smelt. To keep up to date on upcoming surveys, check out CDFW’s web site. (https://www.dfg.ca.gov/delta/data/)

Longfin Smelt Fall Midwater Trawl Index – 1967-2013.

Figure 1. Longfin Smelt Fall Midwater Trawl Index – 1967-2013. The 2014 Index was 16. (CDFW data)

Figure 2.  Catch of adult Longfin Smelt in Winter Kodiak Trawl Survey, Jan-Mar 2015.

Figure 2. Catch of adult Longfin Smelt in Winter Kodiak Trawl Survey, Jan-Mar 2015.

Figure 3.  Longfin Smelt catch distribution in Smelt Larval Survey #5,  early March 2015.  (CDFW data summary)

Figure 3. Longfin Smelt catch distribution in Smelt Larval Survey #5, early March 2015. (CDFW data summary)

Figure 4.  Longfin Smelt catch distribution in Smelt Larval Survey #6,  late March 2015. (CDFW data summary)

Figure 4. Longfin Smelt catch distribution in Smelt Larval Survey #6, late March 2015. (CDFW data summary)

Figure 5.  Longfin Smelt catch distribution in Smelt Larval Survey #5,  early March 2014.  (CDFW data summary)

Figure 5. Longfin Smelt catch distribution in Smelt Larval Survey #5, early March 2014. (CDFW data summary)

Figure 6.  Longfin Smelt catch distribution in Smelt Larval Survey #6,  late March 2015.  (CDFW data summary)

Figure 6. Longfin Smelt catch distribution in Smelt Larval Survey #6,
late March 2015. (CDFW data summary)

Figure 7.  Longfin Smelt catch distribution in 20-mm Survey #1,  mid March 2015.  (CDFW data summary)

Figure 7. Longfin Smelt catch distribution in 20-mm Survey #1, mid March 2015. (CDFW data summary)

Figure 8.  Longfin Smelt catch distribution in 20-mm Survey #1,  mid March 2014.  (CDFW data summary)

Figure 8. Longfin Smelt catch distribution in 20-mm Survey #1, mid March 2014. (CDFW data summary)

Are Delta Smelt Going Extinct?

Recently Dr. Peter Moyle (UC Davis) suggested we “prepare for the extinction of delta smelt”1. Record low summer and fall abundance indices in 2014 following declines over the past decade in the key survey indices have led to major concerns about the future of this endangered species. The first three survey of this winter’s trawl survey brought record lows for January and March (Figure 1). Dr. Moyle and many others are particularly concerned with the March catch of only six adult smelt.

Winter Kodiak Trawl Survey, Delta Smelt Adults

Figure 1. Catch statistics from Winter Kodiak Trawl Survey Jan-Mar 2002-2015. (CDFW data)

Will the record low numbers of Delta Smelt adults be sufficient to bring some recovery when the rains come again as in 2010 and 2011, the last two years with abundant rain and snow before the present drought? As Dr. Moyle pointed out, it is too early to tell. March larval smelt surveys in 2010 and 2011 captured few larvae, as have larval surveys so far this March. This year is different in that the present drought continues whereas the previous drought ended in 2010 and 2011.

Will another year of drought spell disaster for the smelt? That very well may be the case if the State Water Resources Control Board accepts the recent Temporary Urgency Change Petition submitted by the US Bureau of Reclamation and the California Department of Water Resources to change Delta water quality standards. The petition requests relaxation of Delta inflow, outflow and salinity standards, all of which are designed to protect water quality and Delta fish and their habitats, in order to sustain water deliveries to water contractors during the present drought. The changes will undoubtedly lead to higher losses of smelt and further degradation of their freshwater and low-salinity habitat, which could lead to even sharper declines than those apparent during the present and previous droughts. Stay tuned, as we will be keeping close track of events and the Delta Smelt, as well as preparations for their possible extinction.